Shropshire Council

Customer service point opening hours review

  • Period: 12 September 2016 - 07 October 2016
  • Status: Closed
  • Audiences: Everyone
  • Topics: Customer services
  • Type: Public

Some background information

In light of the financial challenges we face due to government spending reductions and rising costs, we have to find ways of making savings across all council services. We also have a duty to make sure that we're using our resources as responsibly and cost effectively as possible in order to maintain services that matter to our residents, particularly those most vulnerable.

What is this consultation about?

Customer Services operates face to face offices all across Shropshire. At our offices, customers can access and get help with many council services.

We recognise the importance of maintaining accessible services for our customers, especially as, increasingly, we help people who have more complex needs or who are unable to use other methods of doing business with us.

The number of customers calling in to see us has reduced by more than half over the last few years (see table), but we've kept the opening hours of our offices unchanged.

Year ended

April 2012

April 2013

April 2014

April 2015

April 2016

Customer numbers

125826

123574

92781

67321

52346

There may be many reasons why we've seen such a large drop in the numbers of people we see, such as the fact that many people now use other means of doing business, including the phone, email or online services. Along with every other part of the council, we have a duty to make sure that we're using our resources as responsibly and cost effectively as possible in order to keep services running.

This consultation isn't about closing our offices. It's about matching the hours that our staff are available at these offices to the changing demand, and to make sure that we spend enough time with those who need our help. This would mean that we could to use our resources more cost effectively, meeting the needs of local people and at the same time using any efficiencies elsewhere. 

For some time our offices have had self-service telephones and public computers installed, and these would remain so that customers could speak to an adviser or go online when the building is open but Customer Services staff are not here.

We have an opportunity to look critically and sensibly at the times we have staff present in our offices, and to make adjustments that are fair to our customers and that still help us to meet the financial challenges we face. 

What are we proposing?

We're proposing changes to the times during which Customer Service staff are in the office and available to help customers at the following offices: Shrewsbury, Oswestry, Ludlow, Bridgnorth, Whitchurch and Market Drayton. 

Below are details of the proposed new opening times for each office:

Shrewsbury

Current opening hours: 

  • (Mon-Fri): 8:30am-5pm

Proposed opening hours: 

  • Mon-Tue and Thur-Fri 9am-4:30pm
  • Wed 9am-4pm
  • Saturday and Sunday closed
  • Proposed opening hours to reduce from 42.5 to 37 hours per week

The recommended opening times will not restrict access to other partner services working out of the building. This is our busiest office, with around 1000 customers calling in to see us each month. Our figures show most customers call in between 10am and midday, and again between 1:30pm and 3:30pm. Opening for these hours each week would allow us 25 minutes on average with each customer.

Ludlow

Current opening hours

  • Mon-Fri 9am - 5pm

Proposed opening hours

  • Mon-Wed 10am-4pm, Thurs 9:30am-4pm, Fri 10am-3:30pm
  • Saturday and Sunday closed
  • Proposed opening hours to reduce from 40 to 30 hours per week

The opening times we recommend won't restrict access to other partner organisations working with us. Our figures show our busiest times to be between 10am and midday, and again between 2:30pm and 3:30pm. Opening for these hours each week would allow us 25 minutes on average with each customer.

Oswestry

Current opening hours

  • Mon-Fri 9am-5pm

Proposed opening hours

  • Mon-Fri 9:30am-4:30pm
  • Saturday and Sunday closed
  • Proposed opening hours to reduce from 40 to 35 hours per week

The Oswestry CSP is located in the library building. Our figures show that most customers call in between 9:30am and 11:45am, and again between 2pm and 3:30pm. Opening for the proposed number of hours per week will allow us to spend 25 minutes on average with each customer.

Market Drayton

Current opening hours

  • Mon-Fri 9:30-4pm

Proposed opening hours

  • Mon 10:30am-3:30pm, Tues 10am-4pm, Weds 10am-3:30pm, Thur 10:30am-3:30pm, Fri 10:30am-3pm
  • Saturday and Sunday closed
  • Proposed opening hours to reduce from 32.5 to 26 hours per week

The times we're recommending won't restrict access to other services working out of the same building. Our figures show our busiest times are between 10am and midday, and again between 2pm and 3pm. Opening for these hours each week would allow us at least 25 minutes on average with each customer.

Bridgnorth

Current opening hours

  • Mon-Fri 9am-5pm

Proposed opening hours

  • Mon-Wed 10am-4pm, Thur 9:30am-4:30pm, Fri 10am-3:30pm
  • Saturday and Sunday closed
  • Proposed opening hours to reduce from 40 to 30 hours per week

The Bridgnorth CSP is located in the library building. The opening times we recommend won't restrict access to other partner organisations working with us. Our figures show busy times for Customer Services as 9:30am to midday and again from 1:30pm to 3pm. These proposed new hours would allow us 25 minutes on average with each customer.

Whitchurch

Current opening hours

  • Mon-Fri 10am-4pm, Sat 10am-1pm

Proposed opening hours

As now, but run by Whitchurch Town Council on Mon-Wed (Sat and Sun closed)

Some time ago we consulted Shropshire citizens over closer working with our local town councils. We intend to work with Whitchurch Town Council, who will help customers on Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays. Our busiest days are Thursday and Friday, and we'll have a member of our staff on site on those days.

What do I need to do?

The survey we're inviting you to complete, available via the 'How to get involved' button on this page, lays out how our customer service points might operate in the future, and what this means for customers. The survey is also available as a hard copy form at your local customer service point.

Please note that no formal decision has been made at this stage.

The information we receive through this consultation will be used to inform any decision making on the future delivery of customer services at these offices. The consultation will run from Monday 12 September to Friday 7 October 2016.

The survey allows you to choose to comment on the office you use, or which is nearest to you, or to make a general comment on our proposals.

The potential impact of any changes on our customers is being assessed through the completion of an equality and social inclusion impact assessment (ESIIA). This is something we complete to show that we've been fair when looking at the needs of customers, especially those who might be affected more by any changes we might make.  

Is there a recommendation or a preferred proposal?

We do have a preferred option that we feel would work, but we'll listen to and consider any other proposals or suggestions that are made through this consultation period.

Our preferred proposal for the future delivery of customer services at the offices named above would be:

  • To continue to run the service for five days a week so that customers who are in need can still access crisis payments and services throughout the working week
  • Customer Service staff will be available to help customers each day, but for a shorter day than now.

The “self-serve” facilities will still be available throughout the day for our customers to use, including the times when Customer Service staff are not on site.  (The public freephone is linked to our customer service centre, which can deal with most enquiries, and public computers can be used for online business). 

Frequently asked questions

What are you proposing?

Fewer customers are calling into our face to face customer service points now, so we're proposing that Customer Service advisers should be available for fewer hours each day to match the new demand.

Why are you doing this?

Over the last few years we have seen the number of customers calling in to see us reduce by more than half but at the same time we have kept our opening hours unchanged.

We need to match our opening hours to the number of customers we're now seeing, but we still need to make sure that we spend enough time with those who need our help. Matching the hours that staff are available more closely to the number of customers calling to see us will also help us to make financial savings across Customer Services.

How much money will this save?

Revising the times when staff are available will contribute to a saving of £227,000 which we're required to make across our service. 

Isn’t this just a cut?

It's easy to see it as that, especially as we have to find savings, but that isn’t what this is about. We know that more and more people go online or use automated payments or the telephone for business. Younger generations want to contact us by new methods, such as online services and social media, and we're building for the future. All of this impacts on the numbers of customers having to call in, and we need to match our hours to this revised demand.    

If I need help, will I still be able to see someone?

Yes you will. This isn't about closing the service. We think it makes sense to look critically at how many hours we staff our offices so that we match this more closely to the reduced number of customers we're seeing.  

Will I have enough time for my enquiry?

Some of the enquiries we help with only take a short time, others may take longer. We've looked at the number of people calling into our offices, the reasons for their visit and the times that people call in, and taken this into account. We believe the proposed opening hours will allow us on average at least 25 minutes with each customer. Some enquiries do take longer than this, but many don't take this long.

Will I have to wait to be seen?

Unfortunately we have peak times at the moment when customers have to wait to be seen, and we appreciate that there will be a settling in period for any new arrangements when this might still be the case. At busy times customers could also use the freephone to the customer service centre, which can help with most things, or use the public computers to contact us as well.     

How many days will you be open for?

We still aim to remain open for five days a week, Monday to Friday. Customer Services is the access point for many council services, but in particular for people who find themselves in crisis (for example at risk of homelessness or require access to local support and prevention payments). We don't feel that days of full closure are appropriate for us, and we believe we should remain accessible.

How many hours per day will you be open?

We've looked at the number of customers calling in, and also at the busiest times of the day and the times that our partner services use the office, and tried to match these up in order to make a recommendation to our customers. Recommendations for each of the service centres can be found on the survey linked to this page via the 'How to get involved' tab.

What happens if I call in and there are no Customer Service staff available?

Either side of the times during which our staff will be present our freephone service will be available for use. This will link you through to our customer service centre, which can deal with most enquiries. We also have free-to-use public computers for those able to do business this way, and these will have “how to” guides attached to them showing how to do things online.

Why can’t the library just run this?

We're looking at ways in which we might be able to work more closely with our colleagues in Library Services, particularly with helping customers to use the phones and computers. Each job requires specialist knowledge, so while we may work more closely together it's less likely that either service can take on the other’s work.     

What will happen to Customer Services staff?

The intention is to redeploy staff to other duties. We're seeing fewer customers face to face which is why we need to review our opening hours, but at the same time we need staff to respond to customers who are coming to us in different ways, such as by phone or social media, and by providing online help such as webchat.

You can give us your feedback on this review either generally or on specific customer service points by completing our survey.

Go to survey »

Data protection

Information collected in our surveys will only be used by us (Shropshire Council) to inform the immediate and future provision of our services. The information you provide will be kept confidential in accordance with our Privacy Policy. It will not be shared outside of Shropshire Council. Information collected via our online surveys (hosted on the Surveymonkey website) will be stored on SurveyMonkey’s servers in the United States of America and SurveyMonkey gives an undertaking never to disclose the survey questions or your responses to others without permission.