Shropshire Council

Future delivery of Ellesmere library and customer service point

  • Period: 02 October 2015 - 16 November 2015
  • Status: Closed
  • Audiences: Everyone
  • Topics: Commissioning, Leisure and culture, Asset management, Customer services, Community and living, Big Conversation
  • Type: Public

About this consultation

We've been consulting with local residents and organisations on the potential transfer of Ellesmere Library and Customer Service Point to a new management organisation and a possible new location.

Open afternoons have been held at Ellesmere Library and the Meres Day Centre for interested individuals and organisations to explore options for the future management and development of the library and Customer Service Point.  Both events were well attended and interest has been expressed to run the library at the Meres Day Centre.

Moving to a new management arrangement organisation, for example a social enterprise with charitable intentions or a local town or parish council, is consistent with our wish to be a commissioning organisation and to identify the best possible solutions for the ongoing delivery and sustaining of valued local services.

This work is also linked to making financial savings and to finding ways of continuing to deliver and sustain high quality services at a lower cost.

We've examined various options and our preferred approach is to transfer the management of the library and Customer Service Point to a new organisation alongside the management of day services for older people and people with learning difficulties within the Meres Day Centre. Key elements of this approach include:

  • Library and Customer Service Point services would be delivered in a new location, the Meres Day Centre. Appropriate alterations would take place to the internal spaces so that different services could be best accommodated alongside each other.
  • The library service maintaining its current opening hours as a minimum requirement with the opportunity for longer open hours in the future.
  • The ongoing provision of a full and comprehensive library service including access to public computers, book, DVD and CD loans, events and activities for adults and children.
  • Support for local residents, within the library opening hours rather than the current more limited current Customer Service Point opening hours, to access Shropshire Council services via a freephone facility or to do their business on-line via a dedicated public computer. Library staff will be on hand for anyone who needs help.
  • The opportunity to create a “community hub” within the Meres Day Centre, a place that people can access a range of information and support on the local community and Council services.
  • Within this approach Shropshire Council would seek to procure a new operator for both library/Customer Service Point services and day services through an open tendering process.
  • Within any resulting contract Shropshire Council would provide support for the delivery of both the library and Customer Service Point, e.g. provision of the books, access to the library management system, training and the support of expert staff.

This option would potentially secure the future of the library and Customer Service Point, providing the opportunity to develop a vibrant community hub offering a diverse range of important community services and support to potentially vulnerable people for the residents of Ellesmere and the surrounding area.

Whilst this is our preferred option, a second proposal is included in this consultation document for the ongoing management by us of the library and Customer Service Point within its existing location at Fullwood House.  To make the same savings as the preferred option the library opening hours would reduce from 20.5 hrs to 10 hrs per week.

Within this consultation document there is also the opportunity for other approaches to be suggested, which would assist us in meeting our required outcomes to reduce costs and deliver a sustainable library service

We have a strong commitment to promoting equality, diversity and social inclusion and the potential impact of the preferred proposal on library users, particularly those who might be more impacted by any change, is being assessed through the completion of an Equality and Social Inclusion Impact Assessment (ESIIA).

A set of frequently asked questions has been produced to help you understand the background and context for the proposals outlined in the consultation, and are available on this page.

We are now seeking responses to the proposals outlined. 

We want to stress that we have an open mind and no formal decision has yet been made and that there is an opportunity to make alternative proposals that can be delivered for the same, or a lower budget than the proposals listed detailed.

The results of the consultation will be collated, analysed and considered, then used to inform a decision on the future delivery of the library and customer service point services in Ellesmere.

A report on the results of the consultation will also be made available on this page and in the library.

To take part, please read through the proposals first, and then complete our short survey which you can access by clicking on the "How to get involved" tab at the top of the page.

Copies of the consultation, survey and frequently asked questions are available from Ellesmere Library, Town Hall, Post Office and Ellesmere Newsagents.

Details of the current library service and Customer Service Point

 

DETAIL

Library and Customer Service Point address

Fullwood House, Victoria Street, Ellesmere, SY12 0AA

Management organisation

Shropshire Council

Area of floor space

Floor area GIA total (gross) in square metres: 121m2

Floor area public (net) in square metres: 103.25m2

Library opening hours

  • Monday Closed
  • Tuesday 10am – 6pm
  • Wednesday Closed
  • Thursday Closed
  • Friday 10am – 5pm
  • Saturday 9.30am to 1pm, 2pm to 4pm

Total = 20.5 hours

Customer Service Point opening hours

Tuesday, 10am - 4.30pm

Parking

Four car parking spaces

1 disabled space

Access to IT / computers

 

Public computers available free to library members

One-to-one adult computer and tablet lessons with trained volunteers

Summary of library services

  • free membership for all
  • the lending of adult books, audio books, large print books and DVDs
  • a children’s library area and range of books for children from age 0 upwards
  • a collection of books for teenagers
  • local history resources
  • regular exchange of books with other libraries
  • request service - obtaining books from other libraries requested by customers
  • free access to public computers for library members; internet access and printing
  • trained staff to issue and return books, answer enquiries, help people to choose books and use computers
  • online services on the Library Service website for use 24/7
  • regular events such as story times, rhyme times, class visits from local schools, adult and teenage reading groups, author talks and social events
  • information and advice on other services, local groups, etc.
  • Volunteers support the delivery of library books to housebound readers.

Library usage

Visits

Visits

Active borrowers

Loans

Computer use / hours

2010/11

25,272

1109

37,857

1,900

2011/12

24,211

1037

34,644

1,819

2012/13

24,613

 989

30,687

1,920

2013/14

24,236

 958

29,477

1,876

2014/15

23,853

 998

28,169

1,596

Summary of services provided by Customer Service Point

 

  • Access to a range of council services and support for people to resolve issues at first point of contact
  • Access to community information to help with everyday queries on health and care, benefits and money, leisure activities, what's on and much more
  • Specialist advice sessions
  • Fee on-line access to information and services.

The principal enquires supported are applications for Blue Badges, Bus Passes, waste and parking

Summary of Customer Service Point usage

 

Year

Annually  

Weekly  

2010/11  

1944

39

2011/12

2927

59

2012/13

1713

34

2013/14

1424

28

2014/15

962

19

Space for community activities

The library provides a meeting space for community groups, e.g. Reading Group, and arrange of activities e.g. children’s story time

Volunteers to support the service

Two volunteers deliver books to housebound readers.

Four volunteers lead the IT learning sessions

One volunteer leads the Reading Group and holds Time to Listen sessions

Three volunteers help shelve the books

Direct costs of running the library and Customer Service Point for Shropshire Council in 2015/16

           

Library - £20,790

Customer Service Point = £4,000

Total = £24,790

 

Options

Option 1

Management of the Library and Customer Service Point by a new provider within the Meres Day Centre (this is our preferred option)

The existing library and Customer Service Point provision relocates to Meres Day Centre, Trimpley Road, Ellesmere.

It is proposed that the day to day running of the services, alongside the management of existing day services for older people and people with learning difficulties, will transfer to a new community focussed organisation (to be confirmed following an open procurement process).

Shropshire Council will provide on-going back office support to the new managing organisation for the delivery of the library and customer services point within a contract that defines roles and responsibilities and support, and will be subject to regular review.

The library opening hours would remain the same as currently, with the potential for these to be extended in the future.

Support for Customer Service Point provision would be improved to align with the library opening hours.  Access to Shropshire council services will be made available via a free phone and dedicated computer and library staff will be on hand for anyone who needs help.

The existing library staff will be transferred to the new management  organisation, which will run the same range of library services currently available to users of the library.

Some alterations will be made to the Meres Day Centre to accommodate the library and Customer Service Point alongside existing day service provision.  This will include a dedicated entrance and space for the library and public computers.

The floor area public (net) in square metres of the library is 103.25.

Identified floor area space for the Library and Customer Service Point in square metres at the Meres Day Centre is 99.88.

The overall aim is for the ‘Meres’ to become a community hub offering day service care for the elderly and people with learning disabilities, library services, a computer suite, coffee shop and meeting room space to enable other organisations to deliver services and provide advice. The community hub would also offer work experience opportunities and increased opportunities for volunteering.

No decision has been taken regarding the future of Fullwood House. In the event that the property is declared surplus to Council requirements, the future use will be considered in the context of the Council’s Asset Management Strategy. This will include the possibility of disposing of the property.

Anticipated saving to Shropshire Council = £8,830 per annum.

Option 2

Library and Customer Service Point remain under Shropshire Council management with reduced opening hours

Ellesmere Library will continue to be run by the Shropshire Council’s library service, which will continue to employ the library staff.

The library opening hours will reduce from the current 20.5 hours per week to 10 hours per week.

The range of library services provided may need to reduce to reflect the reduction in opening hours.

Existing dedicated Customer Service Point provision will be withdrawn.  However, as with option 1 support for local residents to access Shropshire Council services will be provided via a free phone facility and a dedicated public computer. The library staff will also be on hand for anyone who needs help.

Within this option there is a recognition that further financial pressure may come on library and customer service point services and that the on-going review of provision may be necessary.

Anticipated saving to Shropshire Council = £8,830 per annum

Frequently asked questions - general

What is meant by developing library and customer service point services in a way that best meets the needs of the local community?

Shropshire Council is continuing to develop as a commissioning Council and to setting out its future commissioning intentions.  Alongside this the Council is considering which parts of its business might be best delivered locally and will seek to reflect this within its future commissioning intentions.

Specifically the Council wants to work with partners to re-design existing face to face customer focused services including its libraries and customer service points in order to provide places that residents can easily access services and get information and advice that both helps them and enables them to help others within their community.

Our vision is that traditional face to face services will be delivered outside Shropshire Council by community focused enterprises who recognise and support the important role that organisations and individuals who are active in their communities have.

This approach, often referred to as localism, is also a key part of the government’s effort to decentralise power and to support communities to be more empowered and to have a bigger say on the issues that matter to them.

What is your vision for library services redesign in more detail?

We want to:

  • Support the development of modern sustainable libraries achieved by the active involvement of community partners in the day to day operation of the library and the development of self-service facilities. Ongoing “back office” support provided by Shropshire Council.
  • Explore opportunities to co-locate libraries with other services and partners within “community hubs” and to create synergies where appropriate.
  • Provide flexible space to allow for library events such as Rhyme Time, Time to Listen, author events, local history sessions etc.
  • Provide public access computer facilities and free Wi-fi provision.  

What is your vision for customer service point redesign in more detail?

We understand the importance of a face to face service to many of our customers who may not be able to use alternative means of doing business such as over the telephone or online or who need help to use these alternatives.

We want to make sure that people are still able to get the direct help they need, when they need it and we therefore propose working in partnership with other providers, including libraries and parish / town councils, of help and advice in different localities. By doing this, people will be able toaccess a much wider range of help and services than we currently offer.

In addition to direct face to face help, we will install a telephone and a computer both of which will be free to use so that our customers have an extended range of ways to contact us and conduct business with Shropshire Council.

Why can’t Shropshire Council rent out the first and second floors of Fullwood House to provide income for the ongoing management of the library in its existing location?

The cost of upgrading the first and second floors is unlikely to be a cost effective option for Shropshire Council. If during the consultation period a community organisation comes forward with a proposal and a sustainable business model their proposal will be considered as an alternative option

Have you considered options to work with Ellesmere Town Council in the long term management of the library?

The Town Council is committed to supporting the long term future provision of Public Library Services in Ellesmere, either provided or commissioned by Shropshire Council. It will be participating in the consultation process by responding and contributing its views and suggestions. Shropshire Council will be discussing the consultation and options with the Town Council to enable it to form a view as to whether there is any locally appropriate role for it to give consideration.

Frequently asked questions relating to the library

What are the Council’s Statutory Duties to delivery Library Services?

Section 7 of the Public Libraries and Museums Act 1964 (“the PLMA”) states that the council, as a library authority, has a statutory duty (not a discretionary power) to provide a comprehensive and efficient library service for all persons wishing to make use of it.

The PLMA does not define what is meant by “comprehensive and efficient”. However it does provide that the library authority must make facilities for borrowing books and other materials available to people who live, or work, or are undergoing full-time education in Shropshire. It also provides that in fulfilling the duty to provide a comprehensive and efficient library service, it shall in particular have regard to the desirability of:

  • providing facilities for the borrowing of, and reference to, books and other printed matter, pictures, gramophone records, films and other materials in sufficient quantity and quality to meet the general requirements and any special requirement both of adults and children
  • encouraging adults and children to make full use of the library service, providing advice as to its use, and making available such bibliographical and other information as may be required
  • securing co-operation between the library authority and others exercising public functions within the county.

Within the preferred proposal to transfer the day to day management of the library to a new community enterprise organisation Shropshire Council will retain the overall statutory responsibility for library provision.

Will the opening hours of the library change?

Within the preferred option it is planned to at least maintain the existing opening times of the library, and possibly extend them too.

Under option 2 opening hours would be reduced to make the savings.

How will the library be staffed?  Will the existing library staff stay?

The library will still be staffed, but within the preferred option the staff will no longer work for Shropshire Council. Existing staff will have the opportunity to transfer within the TUPE regulations to the new provider.  Under option two the staff will continue to be employed by Shropshire Council.

Will we still be able to request books from other libraries and from libraries outside Shropshire?

Yes, these services will continue as they are now.

What support will the Library Service provide?

Shropshire Council will continue to provide a range of “back office” support functions, principally in access to the library management system, book stock, self-service machines, training, professional support, the support of a librarian based in Ellesmere etc.

The Council’s wish is to help create long term sustainable local approaches. The nature of future roles and responsibilities, support, risk, etc. will be defined within a contract between Shropshire Council and the new provider.

What assurances are there if the new provider can’t continue to run the library?

Shropshire Council will have a contract with the new provider, which will provide them with security. The intention is to regularly review the agreement and to extend it as appropriate.

However, if the new provider can’t run the service for any reason the library would revert back to Shropshire Council who would explore the option of running the library with another local partner.

Are other libraries in Shropshire changing too?

Yes this is part of a wider process across the county. Shropshire Libraries must save £1.3 million over the next 3 year period, and we’re reviewing how services are delivered at all Shropshire’s libraries. Consultations are taking place at a local level through “community conversations”.

Nationally the way libraries are run is also changing, with the community taking a bigger role in the running of libraries, so this process isn’t unique to Shropshire.

Frequently asked questions relating to the customer service point

Will I still be able to get my blue badge and bus pass?

Yes, staff will be able to help you make your application between set times or you can self-serve using the new public computer.

What happens if I need help to fill out a form?

Library staff will be on hand to help and advise if you cannot complete a form.

I can’t use a computer, how will I get help with what I need?

When you see someone at a Customer Service Point they usually do what is needed via their computer, a new public computer will be available and staff will be on hand to help if needed.

If I use the phone at the new points of contact who does it get me through to?

The phones are linked directly to Shropshire Council’s Customer Service Centre who will be able to deal with most things for you.

What sort of services can I get over the phone?

We can provide almost all of the same services over the phone including making payments.

Will the Customer Service Centre opening hours change?

The service will be available for at least the same opening hours as the library, there could be an increase over the current opening times depending on the option chosen.

Will the staff at the library know enough to be able to help me?

Customer Services staff will train the library staff and make sure that they are kept up to date when things change. Also, support will be available via helplines should they need help.

Frequently asked questions relating to a relocation to The Meres Day Centre

What alterations to the current building are you proposing?

Shropshire Council has some funding available from central government to make building alterations that would support a sustainable library managed by a community organisation.

Some early plans have been drawn up for changes to the Meres Day Centre

To accommodate the library.  These would be further developed with key stakeholders should a decision be taken to move the library.

What is the difference in floor space to the existing library?

Floor area public (net) in square metres of the library is 103.25

Identified floor area space in square metres at the Meres Day Centre is 99.88.

Will the Library Services that are available remain the same?

Yes.

How will users access the library?

It is proposed to create a new footpath from the Meres Day Centre onto the corner of Trimpley Road to provide improved pedestrian access.  The library will have it’s own entrance door.

Have you considered the implications for people with disabilities?

Shropshire Council has a strong commitment to working to promote equality, diversity and social inclusion and the potential impact of the preferred proposal on library users, particularly those who might be impacted by any change, is being assessed through the completion of an equality and social inclusion impact assessment.

The building is accessible for wheelchair users. Staff delivering services at the building will receive training to help them assist customers with disabilities to access the range of services available at the building.

Will there be any car parking spaces?

Parking is very limited at the Meres Day Centre.

Public parking is available at the Comrades club for a nominal fee.

How will public access into a Day Care Centre be managed?

Access and safeguarding considerations are a top priority and will be considered very carefully should a recommendation to move the library be confirmed. A separate access will be provided to the library and the library will occupy its own dedicated space.

On the flip side there is an opportunity to involve day care users in the library and the activities that its offers. Some activities might be for the public, others might be for day centre users, and others might be for children and young people.  A joint approach would seek to provide activities for the community as a whole. A community café is already provided within the Meres Day Centre and is supported by volunteers and users of the centre.

The vision is for a community library that is accessible to all, with activities organised accordingly.

Will there be continuous service whilst these changes take place?

Yes, provision will continue within the existing building until alterations are completed within the new building. Some minor disruption may occur when the services are transferred to the new building.

Have you consulted with Ellesmere Community Centre Care Trust trustees on these proposals?

As owners of the building the trust have been fully informed on the proposals and consulted on potential changes to the building to accommodate any changes in use.  They are aware that the building may require some works and we would work with them to ensure minimum disruption to the residents.

Have you consulted with Meres Day Centre users on these proposals?

Consultation has taken place with the users of the day centre and their carers; their main concern was which rooms would be available to them following any changes and they were assured that any areas of the building used by the day centre would be updated and improved if necessary.

They were excited at the prospect of the library coming into the building, as many day centre users are regular visitors to the present library.

What would happen to Fullwood House?

No decision has been taken with regard the future of Fulwood House, whilst it is still an operational Council property. In the event that the property is declared surplus to Council requirements, the future use will be considered in the context of the Council’s Asset Management Strategy. This will include the possibility of disposing of the property. If a disposal is determined as the best option of the Council, the capital receipt generated from the disposal will be used to finance the Council’s countywide capital programme. The Council does not ring-fence capital receipts to the previous occupying service or the geographical area in which the asset is located. Instead they are used to support the overall capital programme, which is allocated on an appraisal basis based on the priorities of the Council.

Having read all the information we've provided, click on the green button to access the short feedback survey to let us know your thoughts on the proposals detailed.

Access the survey »

Data protection

Information collected in our surveys will only be used by us (Shropshire Council) to inform the immediate and future provision of our services. The information you provide will be kept confidential in accordance with our Privacy Policy. It will not be shared outside of Shropshire Council. Information collected via our online surveys (hosted on the Surveymonkey website) will be stored on SurveyMonkey’s servers in the United States of America and SurveyMonkey gives an undertaking never to disclose the survey questions or your responses to others without permission.